Reddish color cast on prints

I recently switched from Photoshop CS5 to CC. I started printing some photos and they come out with a slight reddish cast compared to how they printed before (or the red is printing stronger). On the screen they look like they always have. I use a custom preset for the paper just like in the past. Has anybody else experienced this? Is there a fix? I can try to adjust the red but I would be doing it 'blind' since on the screen there is no red cast.

Thanks for any help!